Harviso - Insights

What is still in China - and what does it really take? A guide for New Zealand and Australian exporters

2024-01-10 08:23 Understanding China
China is one of those markets that New Zealand and Australian exporters think about seriously, but not always simply.

On one hand, the case for paying attention is obvious. For New Zealand, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT) says China is the country's largest trading partner, with two-way trade worth more than NZ$41 billion in the year ending September 2025, and goods exports to China have quadrupled since the New Zealand-China Free Trade Agreement entered into force in 2008. For Australia, China is similarly its largest two-way trading partner, with the China-Australia Free Trade Agreement (ChAFTA) delivering tariff benefits across a broad range of export categories.

On the other hand, many exporters still ask a fair question: beyond the headlines, what is actually in it for me?

That is the more useful question. “China is a big market” is true, but it is not yet a strategy. For an individual exporter, the real issue is whether China offers the right kind of opportunity for their business, and whether the likely return justifies the effort needed to compete there.

The upside is not just scale

The first attraction is scale, but size on its own is not the main reason China matters.

What makes China commercially interesting is that it is large, varied, and layered. It contains mature categories, fast-moving niches, strong local competition, and a wide range of channels to market. For some New Zealand exporters, that means the opportunity is not necessarily “China as a whole”. It may be one segment, one province, one premium channel, one distributor relationship, or one product line that fits the market particularly well.

That matters because it changes how the opportunity should be judged. The question is often not whether a company can “crack China”, but whether it can find a realistic place in it.

Trade access helps, but it does not do the work for you

There is also a practical reason China remains attractive. MFAT says the 2022 upgrade to the New Zealand-China Free Trade Agreement aligned the agreement with newer trade practices and eliminated further tariffs while reducing compliance measures for exporters. NZTE also notes that tariffs have been eliminated for over 98% of New Zealand goods exports to China.

That is meaningful. Better trade conditions lower friction. They can improve margins, reduce complexity, and make a market more commercially viable than it might otherwise be.

But exporters still need to be careful not to confuse market access with market success.

A favourable trade framework can open the door. It does not decide who will sell well, who will find the right partners, or who will build a position that lasts. Those things still depend on the quality of the offer, the clarity of the market proposition, and the discipline of the route to market.

The opportunity today looks broader than it used to

One reason China still deserves attention is that the opportunity is not limited to New Zealand’s traditional export strengths.

NZTE has pointed to continued demand for high-quality food and beverage, while also noting increased growth in areas such as health, nutrition, beauty and wellbeing. In the same vein, MFAT’s recent trade update shows strong export performance across horticulture, dairy and meat, including sharp growth in apple exports into China and continued strength in dairy.

That does not mean every category will succeed. It does suggest, though, that the market is still evolving rather than closing down. For exporters with something distinctive, well-positioned and commercially relevant, China can still offer room to grow.

This is probably one of the most important points for New Zealand businesses. The opportunity is not just about selling more of what has worked elsewhere. In some cases, it may be about recognising where Chinese demand is shifting, and whether the business is equipped to respond to that shift.

What is in it for the exporter?

From an exporter’s standpoint, the potential value usually comes in four forms.

The first is direct revenue. NZTE reported that New Zealand businesses participating in China generated up to NZ$450 million in projected new trade value over 12 months during the 2025 China International Import Expo, with more than 20 commercial signings and activities taking place across a range of sectors.

The second is market diversification. For businesses that do not want to depend too heavily on one region or one customer base, China can still play an important role in a broader export mix. MFAT’s data suggests it remains too significant a market to dismiss lightly.

The third is commercial learning. China tends to expose weak positioning quite quickly. It forces exporters to become clearer about what they are selling, who it is for, how it should be presented, and why it deserves attention. That can be uncomfortable, but it can also be useful. Some of the value is not just in what a company sells there, but in what the market teaches the company about its own competitiveness.

The fourth is long-term credibility. In certain sectors, the ability to operate credibly in China can strengthen a company’s standing elsewhere. It can show that the business can work in a demanding, high-speed market where local expectations are not low.

What exporters often underestimate

The part that is easiest to underestimate is not usually demand. It is execution.

NZTE has described China as a market with new consumer niches, new channels to market, new local competition, and growing preference in some areas for Chinese brands. That is a concise way of saying the market does not stand still for long.

For exporters, that creates a practical challenge. Even when the product is good, the work between “we want to enter China” and “we are now commercially established” can be substantial. That often includes partner selection, local communication, pricing logic, compliance, channel fit, and consistent follow-through after first meetings or first exposure.

This is where a lot of exporters lose momentum. Not because the opportunity was imaginary, but because the middle part of the work was harder than expected.

What this means in practice

For New Zealand exporters, there is still a serious answer to the question, “What is in it for me?”

There is access to one of New Zealand’s most important export markets. There are still favourable trade settings. There is still evidence of real commercial activity, fresh partnerships, and growing opportunity in both established and newer categories.

But the market tends to reward exporters who are precise, prepared and realistic.

So the better question may not be whether China is worth considering. It is whether the business is clear enough about where it fits, what it is trying to achieve, and what kind of market-facing work will be required to make that effort worthwhile.

That is the real takeaway. For New Zealand exporters, China can still offer a great deal. But the value is usually clearer when the opportunity is defined properly, rather than imagined too broadly.

The competitive landscape has changed

A realistic appraisal of what the market offers NZ and AU exporters in 2025 and 2026 needs to acknowledge that the competitive conditions have shifted in ways that matter commercially.

Chinese domestic brands across a wide range of consumer categories have become significantly stronger over the past decade. In some categories - infant formula, dairy, personal care, and consumer electronics are examples - domestic brands have rebuilt consumer trust and commercial sophistication in ways that were not predictable fifteen years ago. For NZ and AU exporters, this means imported origin is a necessary but no longer sufficient differentiator in many categories. The question is not simply whether Chinese consumers prefer imported products. It is whether the specific imported product is genuinely more compelling than the best domestic alternatives, and whether the price premium it commands is justified by what it actually offers.

This is not a pessimistic point. It is a commercially useful one. The NZ and AU exporters who are succeeding in China today tend to be those who are clear about the specific consumer problem their product solves better than domestic alternatives, rather than those who rely primarily on country-of-origin reputation to carry the commercial weight. Provenance matters, but product proposition matters more than it did when Chinese domestic brands were weaker.

The second shift is the increasing influence of younger Chinese consumers - the demographic that has grown up with digital commerce, sophisticated marketing, and direct access to international products through both official and grey market channels. This consumer cohort is brand-literate, comparison-focused, and less deferential to imported origin as an automatic signal of quality. They evaluate products more critically and more contextually. For NZ and AU exporters, engaging this demographic effectively requires a sharper and more specific brand story than broad national reputation alone can provide.

Neither of these shifts makes China less commercially attractive. They do change what it takes to build a durable market position there.

What this means practically

For New Zealand and Australian exporters, the implication is not to avoid China but to enter it with accurate expectations. The market remains one of the world's largest and most commercially active import destinations for the categories where NZ and AU businesses have genuine competitive advantage. What has changed is the degree of commercial specificity required. A product that is good, from a country with a good reputation, no longer travels far on those attributes alone. The businesses that are building durable positions in China today are those that have invested in understanding exactly which consumer segment they are targeting, why their product is distinctively relevant to that segment, and how to reach them through the channels that segment actually uses.